Page 11
wa-ʾidh qataltum nafsan fa-ddāraʾtum fīhā wa-llāhu mukhrijun mā kuntum taktumūna
And when you killed a soul, and accused one another about it—and Allah was to expose what you were concealing—
— Ali Quli Qarai
2Al-BaqarahالبقرةVerse 72 of 286
The Cow2. Al-Baqarahالبقرة
Al Baqarah
The Cow
MedinanVerse 72 of 286
Surah Al-Baqarah, Verses 67-74
And (remember) when Moses said to his people: ‘Surely, Allah commands you that you should sacrifice a cow’. They said: ‘Do you mock us?’ He said: ‘I take refuge with Allah from being one of the ignorant!’ (2:67)
They said ‘Ask your Lord for us to make it clear to us what she is.’ Moses said: ‘He says: Surely she is a cow neither old nor young, but of middle age; so do what you are commanded’ (2:68)
They said: ‘Ask your Lord for us to make it clear to us what colour she should be’. Moses replied: ‘He says she should be a yellow cow, bright in colour, giving delight to the beholders’ (2:69)
They said: ‘Ask your Lord for us to make it clear to us what kind of cow must it be, for surely to us the cows are all alike, and, if Allah wills, we shall surely be guided aright.’ (2:70)
(Moses) said: ‘Verily, He says: Verily, she is a cow not (yet) trained to till the soil or to water the fields; sound and without blemish. They said: ‘Now you have brought the truth’. Then they offered her in sacrifice, though they had not the mind to do (it). (2:71)
And (remember) when you killed a man and disputed thereon: but Allah was to bring forth what you were hiding. (2:72)
So, We said: ‘Strike him (the corpse) with a part of it (the sacrificed cow)’. Thus, Allah gives life to the dead and shows you of His signs, so that you might understand. (2:73)
Then your hearts hardened after that as stones or even worse in hardness; for verily, among stones there are some from which rivers gush forth, and others that split asunder and water issues out of them, and others tumble down through fear of Allah, and Allah is not heedless of what you do. (2:74)
The Story of the Israelites’ Cow
Among what we have already studied about the Children of Israel in Surah Al-Baqarah, all of the facts were mentioned shortly and briefly. The event of the Israelites’ Cow which is referred to in the above verses, in contrast to all of the previous incidents, is explained in detail and comprehensively. This is so, perhaps, for the reason that this story is mentioned in the Qur’an only once. Besides that, there are many instructive subjects involved in it which requires such an extensive explication. One of these subjects which are vividly seen throughout the story is the persistency of the Israelites in seeking for excuses.
It also illustrates their level of faith in the revelations brought forth by Moses (‘a). Most important of all is that the story provides clear emphatic evidence to the possibility of the Resurrection. As it is understood from the Holy Qur’an and its commentaries, the incident was described that one of the Israelites was murdered in a mysterious way, in which his murderer was not at all known. So, there arose a dispute among the different tribes and divisions of the people as to who murdered the man. Every tribe accused the members of another tribe of the crime and announced that the members of its own tribe were innocent.
For its judgement and solution, the problem was brought to the Apostle Moses (‘a). On one hand, that crime was committed hiddenly, and the murderer of the man could not be found by any ordinary means employed at that time. On the other hand, that dispute might have led to a great complicated disturbance among the Children of Israel. Then, finally Moses (‘a), by the help of the Grace and Guidance of Allah and through a miraculous way, whose explanation will come later, solved the problem.
The Qur’an begins the description of the event as thus:
And (remember) when Moses said to his people: ‘Surely, Allah commands you that you should sacrifice a cow’. They said: ‘Do you mock us?’ He said: ‘I take refuge with Allah from being one of the ignorant!’ (2:67)
That is, causing division and mocking others are acts of the ignorant and never is a prophet of Allah of such people. When the Israelites realized that it was not a mockery and the matter was serious,
They said: ‘Ask your Lord for us to make it clear to what she is,’… (2:68)
The phrase: ‘Ask your Lord’ which is repeated several times in their demands, carries a kind of hidden impoliteness and ridicule in itself. It seems that they considered the Lord of Moses (‘a) a different Lord from their own Lord. However, as a reply to their demand:
Moses said: ‘He says: Surely she is a cow neither old nor young, but of middle age;’... (2:68
In order to stop them from prolonging the matter by bringing new excuses forth to postpone that fulfilment of the command of Allah, at the end of the statement, it has been added:
‘...so do what you are commanded’. (2:68)
But, they still continued their insistence and obstinacy.
They said: ‘Ask your Lord for us to make it clear to us what colour she should be’. Moses replied: ‘He says she should be a yellow cow, bright in colour, giving delight to the beholders.’ (2:69)
Anyhow, this cow should be very good and interesting in colour. The colour should be so bright and beautiful that any beholder wonders and becomes delighted when looking at it. It is amazing that they were not satisfied with that and went on seeking for excuses by which, every time, they made the fulfilment of their duty more difficult. A tradition says that Imam Ridha’ (‘a) has said that any cow would have been sufficient, but they imposed the particulars upon themselves, and the more they did so, the more did Allah impose the restrictions as a punishment for their persistent demands for unnecessary details.
All this, while Moses (‘a), acting under inspiration, was driving them to purchase a particular cow belonging to a particular man who was very holy and pious and deserved to be favoured. They had to pay him an enormous price for this cow which was the only one then available. Hence, they were very near to not doing it.2
“They said: Ask your Lord for us to make it clear to us what kind of a cow must it be for surely to us the cows are all alike and, if Allah wills, we shall surely be guided aright’. (2:70)
Again,
(Moses) said: ‘Verily, He says: Verily, she is a cow not (yet) trained to till the soil or to water the fields; sound and without blemish.’ They said: ‘Now you have brought the truth’… (2:71)
So, they tried with much effort to find that particular cow, and, finally, they found it.
...Then they offered her in sacrifice, though they had not the mind to do (it). (2:71)
After describing this story in detail, again the Qur’an retells it briefly, and generally through the following two verses, thus:
And (remember) when you killed a man and disputed thereon: but Allah was to bring forth what you were hiding. (2:72)
So, We said: ‘Strike him (the corpse) with a part of it (the sacrificed cow)’. Thus, Allah gives life to the dead and shows you of His signs, so that you might understand. (2:73)
In the last verse of the verses under discussion, the hardness of the hearts of the Israelites is referred to. It points out that after witnessing all these events and observing the Signs of Allah and the miraculous evidence that Moses (‘a) prepared for them, yet their hearts became hard, even harder than stone, because, there are some rocks that bring forth water, or shatter and fall down for the fear of Allah. It says:
Then your hearts hardened after that as stones or even worse in hardness; for verily, among stones there are some from which rivers gush forth, and others that split asunder and water issues out of them and others tumble down through fear of Allah... (2:74)
So, your hearts are even harder than these rocks, because neither a spring of passion, love, or knowledge flows out of them nor tremble they from the fear of Allah. Then in the last sentence of the verse, it says:
...and Allah is not heedless of what you do. (2:74)
This is a subtle threat against this group of Israelites and all others who behave like them or do the same as they did.
Footnotes