The first issue with this is that Jamil has himself narrated the opposite, as we have mentioned earlier, his statement: ‘Do not say Amin, rather say: al-hamdu lillahi Rabbil-‘alamin.”’ And since he has narrated the contrary of this and what contradicts the current narration and agrees with the narrations of others, it is necessary to judge this solitary narration as invalid, especially since no one else has reported it alongside him. And even if this report were to be authentic, it would be interpreted as having been said under ‘taqiyyah’ (dissimulation). What indicates this is what was narrated:
Commentary #10